April 26, 2023

Bad banks: Things to know

Summary: Bad banks have evolved in the last five decades. They have gained prominence due to crises, such as the 2008 financial crisis and US TARP. They operate globally with some advantages and disadvantages of note. Challenges include pricing conflicts, finding buyers, and potential duplicative support for banks in distress.
A bad bank is a financial institution whose function is to acquire non-performing assets (NPAs) from other banks and financial institutions. Acquiring the NPAs of other banks provides a safety net to them by removing bad loans from their balance sheets and enabling them to lend without constraints. The bad bank can then repackage the bad loans it acquired and resell them to investors. Should the bad bank sell the loan at a higher price than its acquisition cost, it will turn a profit on its operations.
According to McKinsey, a bad bank could have any of the following four structures:
  • The bank could use an on-balance sheet guarantee (often provided by the government) to safeguard a part of its lending portfolio against potential losses.
  • The bank could use a special-purpose entity (SPE) to which the bank would transfer its bad assets. Such an SPE typically receives government support.
  • Another restructuring mode involves the creation of a business unit formed to hold the bad assets. This structure exposes the bank to some risks.
  • Sometimes, a bad bank involves the creation of a new, independent financial institution to which the bad assets are transferred. This structure shields the original bank from the specific risk emanating from the bad assets.

How have bad banks evolved?

Bad banks have been in existence since the 1980s, starting with the creation of the Grant Street National Bank, which assumed the bad assets of Mellon Bank. More recently, bad banks have come into prominence due to the financial crisis of 2008 and the Great Recession, which led to the US government’s Troubled Assets Relief Program (TARP). Besides the US, bad banks have been functioning in several other countries such as Sweden, Germany, and France to address the problem of bad assets on banks’ balance sheets.
In India, the government formed the National Asset Reconstruction Company Limited (NARCL) in July 2021 to address the growing problem of bad assets in public sector banks in the country.

What are the advantages of using bad banks?

  • Consolidation: A bad bank can aggregate all NPAs under a single entity, giving scale and breadth to the bad asset reconstruction effort.
    • Freeing up capital: Once NPAs are transferred to the bad bank, the originating bank can use the provisions made against these bad assets to lend to more credit-worthy customers. According to estimates, as much as INR 5 lakh crore, currently held as provisions against NPAs in India, will be freed up if these bad assets are transferred to a reconstruction entity or bad bank.
    • Capital buffers can improve: Government backing of bad banks generates confidence in lending in originating banks.

What are some of the disadvantages associated with bad banks?

  • Inter-government transfer: Transferring loans from a public-sector bank to a government-backed bad bank merely shifts the onus from one pocket of the government to another. This implies that the incentives available to both entities are essentially the same, and the taxpayer could end up paying for any losses that may arise.
    • Lack of incentives: PSU employees typically lack the profit-generating incentives that are common to privately-owned companies. Hence, government intervention in these financial institutions could result in no real solution to solving the bad debt problem.
    • Moral hazard: Bailout of a commercial bank by the government could disincentivise the entity to exercise caution in its lending policies in the future.

How challenging is the environment for bad banks?

While bad banks offer certain benefits, the ecosystem they function in is fraught with challenges and difficulties.

Price discovery

The NARCL was projected to acquire about INR 2 lakh crore in NPAs at its inception. However, it has acquired only about INR 21,350 crore until July 17, 2023. The financial institution is facing issues in acquiring bad loans from banks due to differences over pricing and future liabilities, according to Reuters. The NARCL is also facing difficulties in transferring bad loans due to differences between the words used in the loan purchase agreements, particularly relating to fraudulent accounts.

Finding buyers

Sometimes finding buyers for a portfolio of risky assets can be challenging, particularly if there is no precedence or market mechanism in place.

Bank recapitalisation

A financial crisis usually results in some form of government intervention. Since the Great Recession of 2008, when the concept of “too big to fail” was floated, governments have often recapitalised banks to help them deal with loan losses. Creating a bad bank for NPAs would imply a duplicate form of government support to originating financial institutions in terms of dealing with bad assets.

In conclusion

While bad banks are a good idea overall, there are issues relating to structural problems within the banking system that still need to be addressed. These include higher lending standards and adequate capitalisation. Besides, until PSU employees embrace greater professionalism, gaps in lending standards and consequently higher NPAs are sure to remain. Therefore, structural reforms of the banking sector need to be instituted.

Disclaimer

The investment options and stocks mentioned here are not recommendations. Please go through your own due diligence and conduct thorough research before investing. Investment in the securities market is subject to market risks. Please read the Risk Disclosure documents carefully before investing. Past performance of instruments/securities does not indicate their future performance. Due to the price fluctuation risk and the market risk, there is no guarantee that your personal investment objectives will be achieved.

Never miss a trading opportunity with Margin Trading Facility

Enjoy 2X leverage on over 900+ stocks

Upstox Margin Trading Facility
Apple Logo
Downloadlogo
iOS App
Google Play Logo
Downloadlogo
Android App

RELATED ARTICLES

Reserve Bank of India - RBI Holidays -2022

Remember ! your good old school calendar in which our favourite page was the list of holidays chalked out at the beginning of each academic year. Just knowing this piece of information meant so much to us. Similarly, within the banking sector, the Reserve Bank of India ( RBI) is the apex body which publishes a detailed list of bank holidays, national and state-wise at the beginning of each calendar year. The RBI, India’s Central bank, also called as the banker’s bank key responsibility is to regulate and supervise the monetary and other banking policies of the financial sector which comprises financial institutions, commercial banks, non-banking financial companies. As an extension to its core responsibilities, the RBI publishes a list of holidays at the beginning of each calendar year. As per the holiday list, whether it is national specific or regional specific, banks would not be operational on those dates. Say for example: Republic Day, Independence Day, and Gandhi Jayanti are the only three National holidays; all other holidays are state-specific. For example: Banks remained closed on September 7-8, 2022 in Kerala for the Onam and Thiruvonam respectively. There will be a bank holiday on September 26, 2022 in Jaipur and Imphal for Navratri Sthapna. This comprehensive list of holidays is in addition to weekend Sunday holidays as well as alternate second and fourth Saturdays holidays during which all Banks across India remain closed. Consequently, the Banks across India would remain open on the 1st, 3rd and 5th Saturdays of every month (as per the notification of the RBI dated 28th August, 2015). The main purpose of declaring this comprehensive holiday list ( details given in Annexure) in advance at the beginning of each calendar year is to make you aware of the impending holidays so that you can plan your banking transactions accordingly with minimal stress. Consequently, it is mandatory for every bank across the Central / State Governments / Union Territories to follow the guidelines issued by RBI. Just to delve a bit deeper, this comprehensive list of holidays published by RBI is categorised as: - State-wise celebrations - Religious holiday - Festival celebrations and the basis of these holidays is governed by: - Holiday under Negotiable Instruments Act Real Time Gross Settlement Holiday - Banks’ Closing of Account The RBI holiday list is applicable to traditional banking transactions. As an netbanking and mobile banking customer, you can access your account 247365. You can also transact through NEFT payment service which is also available for 24×7365 (including bank holidays). However, in case of RTGS ( Real Time Gross Settlement) payment process, the 2nd and 4th Saturdays and all Sundays in a month are RTGS Holidays for every bank in India as per RBI guidelines. Besides, there is a list of additional RTGS holidays 20222 (apart from the already given holidays on 2nd & 4th Saturdays and every Sunday).

Andhra Bank Balance Enquiry Phone Number & How to Check it Online

Balance enquiry is one of the most frequently used banking services. To provide simple and convenient banking services to customers by leveraging technology, Andhra Bank launched a missed call facility on the Andhra Bank balance enquiry number. This facility is available 24X7 and is free of cost. However, there are other ways with which you can check the account balance. For more details, read on.

How to calculate in-hand salary from CTC

The difference between CTC and in-hand salary is what causes much distress to both new and old employees. This blog breaks down the terms, heads, and categories, making it easier to compute in-hand salary from CTC. Have you ever experienced the sudden shock when the amount of salary credited in your account is lower than what you thought was in the offer letter? That is exactly what happens to employees, especially first-timers, when dealing with the complexities of jargon such as statutory, gross, net, bonus, deductions, and taxable components. If these are terms that have troubled you in the past or continue to do so, the following article will help you simplify the CTC in your offer letter and accurately calculate your in-hand salary. Read on!

Canara Bank Balance Enquiry Toll Free Number and How to Check

In India, account holders can inquire about their balances by calling the following toll-free numbers: | 1800-425-0018 | 1800 208 3333 | | --- | --- | | 1800 103 0018 | 1800 3011 3333 | Canara Bank offers its customers a secure and convenient way of accessing their bank accounts. Customers can use online banking, mobile banking, ATMs, etc., to view their Canara Bank account balance. This blog post will outline the steps you need to take to check your Canara Bank balance. So let us get started!