return to news
  1. Will buying health insurance from two companies reduce the likelihood of claim rejection?

Personal Finance News

Will buying health insurance from two companies reduce the likelihood of claim rejection?

Upstox

2 min read | Updated on October 11, 2025, 13:04 IST

Twitter Page
Linkedin Page
Whatsapp Page

SUMMARY

Having two policies from different insurers does not necessarily impact claim decisions. Claim outcomes depend primarily on factors such as the disclosure of pre-existing conditions, policy terms and conditions, waiting periods, etc.

buying health insurance from two companies

Having two policies from different companies can provide a useful backup for certain claim scenarios. | Image: Shutterstock

In contrast to a single policy or top-up, having two distinct policies from two different firms can offer a buffer against claim denial, but there are additional complications involved.

Open FREE Demat Account within minutes!
Join now

Claims may become more complicated as a result of the independent documentation and coordination. Top-up and super top-up plans, on the other hand, provide a more straightforward and affordable means of expanding coverage beyond a base policy, making them easier to administer while maintaining high-value protection.

Instead of taking a top-up from one company, will the chance of insurance getting rejected reduce if I take two policies from two companies?
Answered by Ajay Shah, Head - Distribution, Care Health Insurance
Having two policies from different insurers does not necessarily impact claim decisions. Claim outcomes depend primarily on factors such as the disclosure of pre-existing conditions, policy terms and conditions (T&C), waiting periods for named or pre-existing ailments, etc.

This approach, though, requires managing separate claims and documentation for the respective polices and with multiple insurers, in case there is more than one.

On the other hand, opting for a top-up or super top-up plan can be a more efficient way to enhance coverage. A top-up plan comes into effect once the deductible, generally the base policy sum insured, is exhausted.

For instance, a ₹5 lakh base policy with a ₹25 lakh top-up ensures larger medical expenses are covered beyond the deductible amount. Super top-up plans extend this benefit to multiple claims within a policy year.

These options are more cost-effective and easier to manage when compared to maintaining two separate policies. Individuals should, however, evaluate their respective medical needs and then make an informed choice before buying comprehensive coverage.

Having two policies from different companies can provide a useful backup for certain claim scenarios. However, the best defense against any claim rejection, regardless of how many policies you hold, is complete and honest disclosure of all medical and existing insurance details when purchasing the policies, and diligently following the claim procedure for both.
Meanwhile, starting 22 September, individual life and health insurance policies are exempted from Goods and Services Tax (GST), making premiums more affordable for policyholders. Until now, these insurance services have attracted an 18% GST.
ELSS
Find the best tax-saver funds for 2025.
promotion image

About The Author

Upstox
Upstox News Desk is a team of journalists who passionately cover stock markets, economy, commodities, latest business trends, and personal finance.

Next Story